Now that it’s clear that “Star Wars” creator George Lucas will be taking his artifacts, memorabilia, cartoons and artwork to a town potentially more welcoming to his Museum of Narrative Art than Chicago proved to be, what of the small nonprofit group that fell the mighty filmmaker and his supporter, Mayor Rahm Emanuel?
Friends of the Parks, a nonprofit founded in 1975 with the aim to “preserve, protect, improve and promote the use of parks and open spaces throughout Chicago for the enjoyment of all residents and visitors,” earned U.S. District Judge John Darrah’s support to argue its case. Specifically, that the museum, which was to be erected on lakefront land south of Soldier Field, did not meet the standard of providing a public value strong enough to outweigh the legal precedent set in 1892 to keep the lakefront “forever open, clear and free.”
“There’s more than a 100-year history here in Chicago of protecting our lakefront from development, based on this public trust doctrine, which actually goes back to British law and beyond,” said Friends of the Parks Executive Director Juanita Irizarry.
The land belongs to residents of Illinois, she added. Not the government. “There has to be a very serious inquiry into the balance between the public interest and the private benefit if there is to be development on that land.”
In the days following Lucas’ statement June 24 that he was withdrawing his museum proposal, the preservation group has been both applauded – notably by community activists and Chicago Tribune architecture critic Blair Kamin – and vilified as a group of unelected, elitist, navel-gazing spoilers who stopped a $770 million project (by some reports) that would have attracted additional tourists to the city, from going forward.
Irizarry said some folks were quick to lay blame without fully understanding what was at stake. Others, she said, were well informed but simply didn't agree with the group's stance.
“The decision to leave Chicago was that of Mr. Lucas, not of Friends of the Parks,” Irizarry said.
But not all of the responses have been negative. “We also have lots of folks sending in checks and thanking us for standing firm on defending our lakefront,” Irizarry said.
Some critics have taken to calling the group Friends of the Parking Lot.
“A lot of Chicagoans don’t know the history behind the actual parking lot that we’re talking about,” Irizarry said.
The city agreed to turn the lot into parkland as part of the 1990 McCormick Place expansion project, she said. “But the city has reneged on its commitment to turn that space into parkland and reduce parking spaces on the east side of the drive. They were supposed to have figured out how to get some of that Bears parking over on the west side of the drive, but they have found it more beneficial to take advantage of the revenue that comes from those parking lots.
“It is indeed the city that has been the lover of that parking lot.”
Related 'Chicago Tonight' stories
June 24: The multi-episode saga to build the Lucas Museum of Narrative Art on Chicago’s lakefront is apparently over. In a statement sent just before noon on Friday, “Star Wars” creator George Lucas himself announced that the ongoing litigation from Friends of the Parks effectively killed off the project.
June 15: Friends of the Parks’ executive director Juanita Irizarry insists the lawsuit is still on, but Mayor Rahm Emanuel said Wednesday he believes an agreement can be reached.
June 10: The preservation group Friends of the Parks is denying reports that it will drop a lawsuit against the Lucas Museum of Narrative Art and its quest to build along Chicago’s lakefront.
May 11: Friends of the Parks has made some powerful enemies in maintaining its opposition to any lakefront site for the Lucas Museum. Is it worth losing the museum in order to maintain the sanctity of the lakefront?
May 4: After Friends of the Parks declared its opposition to any lakefront site for the Lucas Museum, Mellody Hobson, wife of movie mogul George Lucas and board member of the Lucas Museum, said they were “seriously pursuing locations outside of Chicago.”
May 3: “We are now seriously pursuing locations outside of Chicago,” Mellody Hobson, wife of movie mogul George Lucas and board member of the Lucas Museum, said in a statement. “If the museum is forced to leave, it will be because of the Friends of the Parks and that is no victory for anyone.”
April 26: As Mayor Rahm Emanuel pushes McCormick Place as the new location for the Lucas Musuem, a group of faith and community leaders met Tuesday to throw their support behind the plan. WBEZ's Lauren Chooljian will bring us the latest.